Chief Justice Renato Corona has not given up on his resolve to scrutinize how congressmen led by members of President Benigno Aquino III鈥檚 Liberal Party prepared and transmitted the impeachment complaint against him last month.
Corona has filed another motion asking senators to grant his previous request for a preliminary hearing to ascertain the validity of the complaint.
The Chief Justice said a preliminary hearing would allow his camp 鈥渢o prove (its) allegation鈥� that there were 鈥渇atal defects鈥� in the impeachment complaint.
In his motion to admit reply to comment filed late Thursday, the Chief Justice said that prosecutors from the House of Representatives 鈥渉ave refused to explain how it was physically possible for 188 congressmen to read, understand and evaluate the 188-page complaint and annexes within a short period of time.鈥�
Corona was referring to the incident on Dec. 12, 2011, when Mr. Aquino鈥檚 allies rallied other congressmen behind the impeachment complaint. It was presented to them and was approved for transmittal to the Senate that same day.
A number of House members later complained that they were not able to read the documents. But others admitted signing the complaint anyway after a caucus wherein House leaders made a PowerPoint presentation on the impeachment complaint.
鈥淲hile the House of Representatives has the power to initiate impeachment cases, the manner of its exercise must be made in accordance with the Constitution. Hence, this Honorable Impeachment Court has the power to determine if the power was exercised under the Constitution,鈥� Corona said in the new motion.
Corona said it would be 鈥渁bsurd鈥� that the impeachment court would be 鈥渙bliged to entertain an impeachment case and hold a trial on the merits even if the complaint flagrantly violated the requirements of the Constitution.鈥�