12 senators seek probe into ‘state-funded troll farms’
FILE PHOTO/REUTERS/Kacper Pempel/Illustration
MANILA, Philippines — Twelve senators on Monday called for a Senate investigation into allegations that public funds are being used to run “troll farms,” which one lawmaker said was “dangerous for democracy,” particularly as elections draw near.
“Filipinos should know why government spends public funds on troll farm operators disguised as ‘public relations practitioners’ and ‘social media consultants’ who sow fake news rather than on Covid-19 assistance, health care, food security, jobs protection, education, among others,” read the Senate Resolution No. 768, which was signed by 12 senators.
The resolution sought to direct an inquiry into state-backed and state-funded spreaders of misinformation.
The senators’ call for a probe comes after Senator Panfilo Lacson earlier revealed that an undersecretary has allegedly set up at least two troll farms throughout the country to discredit critics of the administration and potential opponents in 2022.
READ: Lacson: ‘Usec’ organizing troll farms vs critics, admin rivals in 2022 polls
Article continues after this advertisementREAD: Lacson: Ability to ‘maintain, create troll farms’ advantage of admin candidates in 2022
Article continues after this advertisementA social media troll, the resolution noted, is “someone who creates conflict on sites like Twitter, Facebook, and Reddit by posting messages that are particularly controversial or inflammatory with the sole intent of provoking an emotional response from other users.”
Citing the need for an investigation, the resolution also pointed out that the Department of Finance had earlier awarded a P909,122 communications strategy consultancy contract to a public relations practitioner who was tagged by Facebook itself as the “operator behind a pro-Duterte fake account network which Facebook took down in March 2019.”
Further, the resolution noted that the Department of Foreign Affairs (DFA), in 2017, had a “similar social media consultancy contract with a known pro-administration blogger who has been accused of peddling fake news and spreading hateful comments against critics of the administration.”
“The Duterte administration even appointed some of these bloggers and social media personalities to high positions in various departments and agencies in government,” it added.
“[T]he above instances illustrate that troll farms and the misinformation and fake news that they propagate may be state-backed and state-funded. In this connection, Congress should look into government funds that are used to fund misinformation and fake news that affect millions of Filipinos,” the resolution further read.
According to the senators, allegations of the use of public funds for the operation of “troll farms” cannot be dismissed given that Filipinos regularly use social media sites such as Facebook, making them vulnerable to internet trolls.
They noted a 2020 annual report of advertising firms We are Social and Hootsuite showing Filipinos spend an average of four and 15 minutes each day on social media, taking the top spot for the sixth straight year.
The Philippines is also the highest in the world in internet usage with an average of 10 hours and 56 minutes, the resolution added.
The resolution was signed by Senate President Vicente Sotto III, Senate President Pro Tempore Ralph Recto, Minority Leader Franklin Drilon, and Senators Nancy Binay, Leila de Lima, Richard Gordon, Risa Hontiveros, Panfilo Lacson, Emmanuel Pacquiao, Francis Pangilinan, Grace Poe and Joel Villanueva.
“Pagsisinungaling ang trolling. Masama ito lalo na dahil sa darating na halalan. Kung mahalal ang bagong presidente at ibang opisyal dahil sa pekeng impormasyon, magkakaroon tayo ng pekeng presidente at opisyal,” Pangilinan said in a statement.
(Trolling is lying. It is evil, especially that we have an upcoming election. If people elect a president and other officials because of the fake information spread by paid trolls, then similarly we will have a fake president and fake officials),” Pangilinan said.
“Dapat mag-invest sa totoong farms ng mga gulay at prutas, hindi sa troll farms,” he added.
(Invest in real farms of vegetables and fruits, not troll farms.)
Pangilinan pointed out that false information and misinformation can cause harm to the nation, which is fighting the COVID-19 pandemic.
“Hindi natin pwedeng hayaang ginagamit ang pera ng taumbayan para manira at mang-harass ng mga taong pumupuna sa gobyerno. Masama ito sa demokrasya, lalo na sa papalapit na halalan sa susunod na taon,” he said.
(We must not let pass the use of taxpayers’ money to malign and harass people who are critical to the government. This is dangerous for democracy, especially that elections are upcoming next year.)
