House Oversight Committee Ranking Member Rep. Jamie Raskin (D-MD) speaks as his aides hold boxes of what he said were thousands of pages of Biden family bank records subpoenaed by the committee as Chairman James Comer (R-KY) looks on during a House Oversight and Accountability Committee impeachment inquiry hearing into U.S. President Joe Biden, focused on his son Hunter Biden鈥檚 foreign business dealings, on Capitol Hill in Washington, U.S., September 28, 2023. (REUTERS)
WASHINGTON聽 鈥� Republicans leading an impeachment inquiry of President Joe Biden detailed foreign payments to members of his family in their first hearing on Thursday, but did not provide evidence that the Democratic president had personally benefited.
The initial impeachment hearing by the U.S. House of Representatives Oversight Committee served as a review of evidence that Republicans have gathered so far about foreign business ventures by Biden鈥檚 troubled son Hunter Biden, 53, which they say shows that Biden鈥檚 family members were selling access.
鈥淭he American people demand accountability for this culture of corruption,鈥� House Oversight Committee chair James Comer said. He said Biden has lied about family members鈥� business dealings and had not walled them off from his official duties.
Democrats and several independent witnesses said there was no proof that Biden had received any of those payments, or otherwise engaged in improper behavior while he served as vice president between 2009 and 2017. The White House has denied wrongdoing and dismissed the probe as politically motivated.
鈥淚f Republicans had a smoking gun or even a dripping water pistol they would be presenting it today. But they鈥檝e got nothing,鈥� said Jamie Raskin, the panel鈥檚 top Democrat.
Biden is campaigning for reelection in what will be a likely rematch with Republican Donald Trump, who is preparing for four upcoming criminal trials on a range of charges, from trying to overthrow his 2020 election defeat to mishandling classified documents are leaving office.
Trump, who was impeached twice during his four years in office, and some of his hardline Republican allies have for months called for a Biden impeachment.
Democrats prominently displayed a clock counting down the minutes until midnight Saturday, when the U.S. government will enter its fourth partial shutdown in a decade if Congress fails to pass legislation to fund federal agencies.
George Washington University professor Jonathan Turley and forensic accountant Bruce Dubinsky said the panel had enough evidence to open an impeachment inquiry but did not have enough evidence to justify impeachment charges.
Another law professor, Michael Gerhardt of the University of North Carolina, said he had not heard credible evidence to justify the probe and warned the panel that it was being driven by partisan concerns.
A fourth witness, former Justice Department official Eileen O鈥機onnor, said she thought the department had soft-pedaled a criminal investigation of Hunter Biden, who now faces gun charges after years of struggling with drug and alcohol addiction.
Republicans allege Biden and his family profited from policies he pursued as vice president during former President Barack Obama鈥檚 administration between 2009 and 2017. Separately, they also allege the Justice Department interfered with the criminal investigation of Hunter Biden.
UNCLEAR PROSPECTS
It is unclear if House Republicans, who have a narrow 221-212 majority, would have the votes at the end of the inquiry to support actual impeachment. But even if that vote succeeded, it is highly unlikely that the Senate, where Democrats hold a 51-49 majority, would vote to remove Biden from office.
At the center of the investigation are allegations that Biden, as vice president, pressured Ukraine to fire a top prosecutor to shield Burisma, a company for which Hunter Biden was on the board of directors.
Numerous U.S. and foreign officials have said Biden was carrying out official policy to fight corruption in Ukraine.
Democrats unsuccessfully pressed the panel to subpoena former New York Mayor Rudolph Giuliani, who had sought to uncover evidence of Biden wrongdoing in Ukraine, as well as Lev Parnas, a former associate who has denounced Giuliani鈥檚 effort.
House Republicans have said they plan to seek personal and business bank records for Hunter Biden and James Biden, the president鈥檚 brother.
Comer cited payment records from Chinese nationals to Hunter in 2019, listing Joe Biden鈥檚 home address in Delaware as the beneficiary address. Republicans have not provided evidence that the elder Biden received the money.
鈥淥nce again Rep. Comer peddles lies to support a premise 鈥� some wrongdoing by Hunter Biden or his family 鈥� that evaporates in thin air the moment facts come out,鈥� said Hunter Biden鈥檚 attorney, Abbe Lowell, in a statement on Thursday. Lowell said the money in question was a loan and that the address listed was the address on Hunter Biden鈥檚 driver鈥檚 license at the time.
The White House said Republicans should focus on reaching a deal to keep the government open on Oct. 1, the start of the new fiscal year.
鈥淭he consequences for the American people will be very damaging,鈥� the White House said at the hearing鈥檚 outset. 鈥淣othing can distract from that.鈥�