Solicitor General Jose Calida unwittingly torpedoed his attempt to oust Chief Justice Maria Lourdes Sereno by admitting that she had indeed filed statements of assets, liabilities and net worth (SALNs) when she was still a law professor, one of the top magistrate鈥檚 spokespersons on Saturday said.
In a statement, Josalee Deinla also belied Calida鈥檚 claim that it was the Office of the Solicitor General that retrieved Sereno鈥檚 SALNs covering the years 1985, 1990, 1991, 1993, 1994, 1995, 1996 and 1997 鈥� when she was teaching law at the University of the Philippines.
She pointed out that the Chief Justice had informed the Supreme Court that she already found the missing documents through a petition she filed last March 19 鈥� or more than two weeks before Calida submitted copies of Sereno鈥檚 SALNs to the tribunal.
Nonetheless, she said the Calida鈥檚 admission should now prompt the high court to toss out his quo warranto petition against Sereno.
鈥淐alida鈥檚鈥� petition was based on his claim that since Sereno did not file [her] SALNs, she failed to meet the constitutional requirement of proven integrity,鈥� Deinla said.
鈥淗is submission is an admission that his petition is baseless. The recovery of most of the SALNs destroys (his) main argument that the Chief Justice should be removed from office,鈥� she added.
Deinla noted that Sereno had previously declared that she would present her recovered SALNs before the Senate, which is expected to convene as an impeachment court following President Rodrigo Duterte鈥檚 order to the House of Representatives to hasten its proceedings against the Chief Justice.
鈥淭he Chief Justice鈥� intends to present the鈥� SALNs to the Senate impeachment court without prejudice to her legal defenses (since) her alleged failure to file SALNs before she joined the (judiciary) is not within the scope of the impeachment complaint or the grounds for impeachment (as) provided in the Constitution,鈥� Deinla said.
On Friday, Calida called Sereno a 鈥渓iar鈥� after Jojo Lacanilao, a member of her legal team, disclosed that they had retrieved copies of the SALNs which the Chief Justice had filed more than two decades ago. /atm